Page "Sense and reference" Paragraph 32
from
Wikipedia
Russell held the view that most of the apparent proper names in English are in fact " disguised definite descriptions ".
So " Aristotle " is understood as " The pupil of Plato and teacher of Alexander ", or by some other unique description.
But Russell also held the view ( not evident in the Mont Blanc example ) that most of the " proper names " in English are not names at all, but descriptions in disguise.
Possibly the only real proper names were demonstrative pronouns like this and that ( directed at an object that can be immediately perceived ).
So in fact if Frege's view was " descriptivist ", then he effectively agrees with Russell on most of the apparent " proper names " of ordinary language: Frege thinks that " Aristotle " is a name, with a sense, which is equivalent to some description.
Russell thinks that Aristotle is not really a name, but is ( in disguised form ) just such a description.
Page 1 of 1.
1.848 seconds.