Historian John Huddleston estimates the death toll at ten percent of all Northern males 20 – 45 years old, and 30 percent of all Southern white males aged 18 – 40.

Historian John Lewis Gaddis has summarized the turnaround in evaluations by historians:

Historian John Rodden stated: " John Podhoretz did claim that if Orwell were alive today, he ’ d be standing with the neo-conservatives and against the Left.

Historian John Toland relates a story by Günter Syrup, a subordinate of Heydrich.

* John S. Brown, United States Army brigadier general ; Chief Historian of the United States Army Center of Military History

Historian Jim Bradbury has summarised the contemporary historical opinion of John's positive qualities, observing that John is today usually considered a " hard-working administrator, an able man, an able general ".

Historian John Morris made the putative reign of Arthur the organising principle of his history of sub-Roman Britain and Ireland, The Age of Arthur ( 1973 ).

Historian John Erickson dates 1 February 1924, when Mikhail Frunze became head of the Red Army Staff, as the ascent of the General Staff, which dominated Soviet military planning and operations.

Historian John Hedley Brooke describes wide variations: " the natural sciences have been invested with religious meaning, with antireligious implications and, in many contexts, with no religious significance at all.

Historian John Stow, writing in his Survey of London ( 1598 ), noted ' this place is called the Star Chamber, because the roof thereof is decked with the likeness of stars gilt ...' The chamber's description is regarded as the most likely explanation for its name by the editors of the Oxford English Dictionary.

Historian John Laband dismisses these stories as myth.

Historian John Hicks claims that the United States has never possessed for any considerable period of time the two party system in its pure and undefiled form.

" Historian and former White House Counsel John Dean's reassessment of Harding stated his accomplishments included income tax and federal spending reductions, economic policies that reduced " stagflation ", a reduction of unemployment by 10 %, and a bold foreign policy that created peace with Germany, Japan, and Central America.

Historian John M. Cooper argues that, in his first term, Wilson successfully pushed a legislative agenda that few presidents have equaled, and remained unmatched up until the New Deal.

Historian John Brooks in his book Once in Golconda considered the turn of the 19th to 20th century period to have been Wall Street's heyday.

Historian and Point du Sable biographer John F. Swenson has called these claims " elaborate, undocumented assertions ... in a fanciful biography ".

* Peter W. Edbury and John G. Rowe, William of Tyre: Historian of the Latin East.

Historian John Thornton noted, " A number of technical and geographical factors combined to make Europeans the most likely people to explore the Atlantic and develop its commerce.

Historian and former MP and Trudeau biographer John English said " I don't think it does any good to do this kind of historical ransacking to try to destroy reputations ".

Historian John Mack Faragher cautions that the folk image of Boone as semiliterate is misleading, however, arguing that Boone " acquired a level of literacy that was the equal of most men of his times.

Historian John Birkenmeier has recently argued that John's reign was the most successful of the Komnenian period.

Historian John Burnham interviewed Watson late in life, and portrayed him as a man of ( still ) strong opinions and some bitterness towards his detractors.

Historian John D. Post has called this " the last great subsistence crisis in the Western world ".

Historian John D. Winters in The Civil War in Louisiana ( 1963 ), describes Sabine as " a poor piney-hill parish met earlier obligations to her men by voting funds for the Sabine Rifles, Sabine Rebels, Sabine Volunteers, and Jordan's Company, and sent $ 500 to another company already departed for the front.

Historian Mark Stoyle suggests that she was probably taught Cornish by William Killigrew, Groom of the Privy Chamber and later Chamberlain of the Exchequer.

Historian James Lockhart suggests that the people needed to have a scapegoat for the Aztec defeat, and Moctezuma naturally fell into that role.

Historian Barbara Bell suggests that the paintings may have been made for tourists on Seneca Lake boat tours

Historian David Crouch suggests that Stephen effectively " bowed out of Wales " around this time to concentrate on his other problems.

Historian Stanley Jones, in his study of the 1896 election, suggests that western Democrats would have opposed Cleveland even if the party had held its congressional majority in 1894 ; with the disastrous defeat, they believed the party would be wiped out in the West if it did not support silver.

Historian Trevor Royle suggests that due to Somerset's mistrust of Warwick, the duke would rather await his queen and her army than to voluntarily aid the earl.

Historian Alan Stewart suggests that many of the phenomena now seen as peculiarly Jacobean can be identified more closely with Anne's patronage than with James, who " fell asleep during some of England's most celebrated plays ".

Historian David Crouch suggests that Stephen effectively " bowed out of Wales " around this time to concentrate on his other problems.

Historian H. P. R. Finberg suggests that the foundation charter may have been drafted in the 9th century, based on some authentic material.

Historian Oliver Creighton suggests that the ideal image of a castle by the 1750s included " broken, soft silhouettes and decayed, rough appearance ".

Historian Ian Jones suggests the story still had an " indefinable appeal " for Australians in the early twentieth century.

Historian Fernand Braudel suggests that in Cairo in the 11th century Muslim and Jewish merchants had already set up every form of trade association and had knowledge of every method of credit and payment, disproving the belief that these were invented later by Italians.

Historian William Marvel suggests that since both Anderson and Johnson acknowledged their own reliefs, " There is therefore no reason to suspect an order would not have been issued relieving Pickett, both because his division had been shattered beyond repair and because of his allegedly poor performance at Five Forks.

Historian Ian Beckett suggests around 12, 000 could be regarded as reliable, but even these proved reluctant to move in on the crowd, since it included so many women.

Historian A. G. Morice suggests that the phrase " Red River Rebellion " owes its persistence to alliteration, a quality that made it attractive for publication in newspaper headlines ( Critical History of The Red River Insurrection ).

Historian Robert C. White suggests that the " very eminent person " written of by Echard was his colleague Edmund Bohun, and chose not to mention Bohun because he became associated with the Jacobite movement.

Historian Robert McKenzie suggests that the hostility of Northern Methodists ( who were abolitionists ) toward Southern Methodists ( who tended to be pro-slavery ) in the 1840s may have driven Brownlow into the pro-slavery camp.

Historian Michael Marquardt argues that the evidence suggests the organization occurred in Manchester, and that the confusion was likely due to the effect of memory tending to conflate memories of several meetings in Manchester and Fayette years earlier Critics suggest that the location of the organization was intentionally changed in 1834 around the same time the church's name was changed to the " Church of the Latter Day Saints ", in order to make it seem like the new church organization was different from the " Church of Christ ", as a tactic to frustrate the church's creditors and avoid payment of debts.

Historian Winfried Ludecke suggests that, upon leaving Port Arthur, Manchuria, Reilly voyaged to Imperial Japan in the company of an unknown mistress.

The exact length of his reign is not known ; the Turin canon suggests an improbable 95 years while the ancient Greek Historian Manetho reports that the reign of " Boëthôs " lasted for 38 years.

Historian Robert Liddiard suggests that on the basis of the views from the castle at this time, the structured nature of the parks would have contrasted with the wilderness of the mountain peaks framing the scene beyond, making an important statement about the refinement and cultured nature of the castle lord.

Historian David Balfour suggests that Eve was the daughter of Gilbert de Lacy, the son of Roger de Lacy, exiled by King William II in 1095 for rebellion.

Historian D. P. Kirby suggests that Wiglaf's death occurred in 839, basing this date on the known chronology of the reigns of Beorhtwulf and Burgred, the next two Mercian kings.

Historian David Crane suggests that if Borchgrevink had been a British naval officer, England would have taken his achievements more seriously.