[permalink] [id link]
In a dissenting opinion, Justice Harry Blackmun, joined by Burger and Black, suggested that Cohen's wearing of the jacket in the courthouse was not speech but conduct ( an " absurd and immature antic ") and therefore not protected by the First Amendment.
from
Wikipedia
Some Related Sentences
dissenting and opinion
The U. S. argument was affirmed, however, by the dissenting opinion of ICJ member U. S. Judge Schwebel, who concluded that in supporting the contras, the U. S. acted lawfully in collective self-defence in El Salvador's support.
When the Court renders its decision, it will generally do so in a single majority opinion and one or more dissenting opinions.
The Thought Police are those who suppress all dissenting opinion.
A dissenting opinion is presented by followers of the Maliki school of Islamic jurisprudence, who argue that non-Muslims may not be allowed into mosques under any circumstances.
While only the majority opinion is considered precedential, an outvoted judge can still publish a dissenting opinion.
In his widely cited dissenting opinion in Olmstead v. United States ( 1928 ), Brandeis relied on thoughts he developed in his Harvard Law Review article in 1890.
On October 1, 2008, the Court declined to reconsider its opinion in this case, but did amend the majority and dissenting opinions in order to acknowledge that federal law.
Likewise, Justice Antonin Scalia has expressed the same view, in the dissenting opinion of Troxel v. Granville 530 U. S. 57 ( 2000 ):
In a separate dissenting opinion, Justice Stevens also challenged the virtue of an individual reward, analyzing it from the perspective of patent law.
However, the matter was addressed in separate and dissenting opinions, such as the separate opinion of President Guillaume who concluded that universal jurisdiction exists only in relation to piracy ; and the dissenting opinion of Judge Oda who recognised piracy, hijacking, terrorism and genocide as crimes subject to universal jurisdiction.
Justice Douglas, dissenting in Wheeling Steel Corp. v. Glander ( 337 U. S. 562, 1949 ), gave an opinion similar to, but shorter than, the one quoted above, to which Justice Black concurred.
Indeed, Chief Justice William Rehnquist repeatedly criticized the Court's invention of corporate constitutional " rights ," most famously in his dissenting opinion in the 1978 case First National Bank of Boston v. Bellotti.
Justice Frank Murphy offered a dissenting opinion, stating that the Court was effectively giving the FCC a power to regulate networks which had not been given to the FCC by Congress.
* The concurring opinions of Burger and Douglas, as well as White's dissenting opinion, were issued along with Doe v. Bolton and may be found at:
" The Los Angeles Timess Kevin Thomas issued a dissenting opinion when he reviewed the shortened film, becoming one of its few American champions and calling it " a true screen epic.
These lists contain detailed tables about each term, including which Justices filed the Court's opinion, dissenting and concurring opinions in each case, and information about Justices joining opinions.
Justice Hamilton R. Gamble, a future governor of the state, sharply disagreed with the majority decision and wrote a dissenting opinion.
He is also memorialized there with an official Michigan Historical Marker and a plaque from the State Bar of Michigan for " Michigan Legal Milestones ", namely, his dissenting opinion in Korematsu v. United States, protesting the decision to uphold exclusion orders imposed upon persons of Japanese descent during World War II.
Justice O ' Connor, dissenting in Gonzalez ( transcript ), began her opinion by citing United States v. Lopez, which she followed with a federalist reference to Justice Louis Brandeis's dissenting opinion in New State Ice Co. v. Liebmann.
dissenting and Justice
Chief Justice John Roberts rejected this reasoning and this rationale was not cited in any dissenting justice opinions.
Justice Breyer, who dissented, wrote in his most recent book that if he could change three of his dissenting opinions ( while on the Supreme Court ) into a majority, this would be one of them.
However, a dissenting school of thought often found in the opinions of Justice Antonin Scalia is that searches must simply be " reasonable ," and the warrant requirement has been overly emphasized.
Nonetheless, these justices ' rulings have continued to affirm the assumption of corporate personhood, as the Waite court did, and Justice Rehnquist himself eventually endorsed overruling " Austin ," dissenting in McConnell v. FEC.
In Snyder v. Phelps ( 2011 ), dissenting Justice Samuel Alito likened the protests of the Westboro Baptist Church members to fighting words and of a personal character, and thus not protected speech.
See San Diego Gas & Electric Co. v. City of San Diego, 450 U. S. 621, 638 n. 2 ( 1981 ) ( Justice Brennan dissenting ); United States v. Clarke, 445 U. S. 253, 257 ( 1980 ); Agins v. City of Tiburon, 447 U. S. 255, 258 n. 2 ( 1980 ).
Justice Douglas ' dissenting opinion held that:
The decision was rendered 5-4, with Chief Justice Salmon P. Chase and Justices Wayne, Swayne and Miller dissenting, and Chief Justice Chase pronouncing a forcible protest.
In Poe, Justice John Marshall Harlan II filed one of the most cited dissenting opinions in Supreme Court history.
Chief Justice Warren E. Burger and Associate Justices William H. Rehnquist ( later Chief Justice ) and Byron White issued dissenting opinions.
In California v. Minjares, Justice William Rehnquist, in a dissenting opinion, wrote " he most comprehensive study on the exclusionary rule is probably that done by Dallin Oaks for the American Bar Foundation in 1970.
" Justice O ' Connor in her dissenting opinion also stated that " a single courageous State may, if its citizens choose, serve as a laboratory ; and try novel social and economic experiments ," and that " his case exemplifies the role of states as laboratories.
dissenting and Harry
A sharply worded dissenting opinion by Justice Harry Blackmun attacked the majority opinion as having an " almost obsessive focus on homosexual activity.
In the dissenting opinions, Justices Harry A. Blackmun, Warren E. Burger, Lewis F. Powell, Jr., and William H. Rehnquist suggested that the result of this ruling would be the elimination of publicly supported single-sex educational opportunities.
dissenting and Blackmun
Blackmun wrote a dissenting opinion which focused on the plurality's desired narrowing of Roe as described in the section on the viability testing requirement.
dissenting and joined
Justice Thomas, joined by Justice Scalia, issued a strongly worded opinion, concurring in part and dissenting in part, arguing that if Michigan could not remain a prestigious institution and admit students under a race-neutral system, the " Law School should be forced to choose between its classroom aesthetic and its exclusionary admissions system.
Minton joined with Chief Justice Fred M. Vinson and Justice Stanley Forman Reed in the dissenting opinion that the President had the authority through the war powers clause of the constitution.
The lower court's decision was affirmed by the appeals court, with BOWMAN, Circuit Judge, joined by ROSS and FAGG, Circuit Judges, dissenting.
Justice John Marshall Harlan wrote a dissenting opinion, which was joined by Justices White and Day.
Douglas, joined by Black, furthered his advocacy of a broad reading of First Amendment rights by dissenting from the Supreme Court's decision in Dennis v. United States ( 1952 ) affirming the conviction of the leader of the U. S. Communist Party.
It was formed in 1994 out of the Great Front ( Frente Grande ), which had been founded mainly by progressive members of the Peronist Justicialist Party who denounced the policies and the alleged corruption of the Carlos Menem administration ; the Frente joined with other dissenting Peronists, the Unidad Socialista and several other leftist parties and individuals.
In 1898 Harlan joined Chief Justice Fuller's dissent in United States v. Wong Kim Ark, dissenting from the Court's holding that persons of Chinese descent born in the United States were citizens by birth.
The court opinion was written by William Rehnquist ; a dissenting opinion was written by Thurgood Marshall, who was joined by Chief Justice Warren E. Burger.
Chief Justice Warren E. Burger joined the dissenting opinion.
Despise the fears of progressives, Stone quickly joined the Court's " liberal faction ," frequently dissenting with Justices Holmes and Brandeis and later, Cardozo when he took Holmes ' seat, from the majority's narrow view of the police powers of the state.
Justice Antonin Scalia filed a dissenting opinion and was joined by William Rehnquist and Clarence Thomas.
* Justice Kennedy, joined by the Chief Justice, issued a 68-page dissenting opinion and appendix, noting that BCRA forces " speakers to abandon their own preference for speaking through parties and organizations.
A dissenting opinion was written by Chief Justice Rehnquist, joined by Justices Scalia and Thomas.
However, four years later Swayne joined the majority in Munn v. Illinois, with Field and Bradley still dissenting.
The Court split 5-4, with Justice Stephen Breyer filing a dissenting opinion in which he was joined by Justices John Paul Stevens, David Souter, and Ruth Bader Ginsburg.
Justice Jackson wrote a dissenting opinion in which he was joined by Justice Frankfurter.
Justice Rutledge wrote another dissenting opinion in which he was joined by Justices Frankfurter, Jackson and Burton.
Breyer, J., filed a dissenting opinion, which Kennedy and Alito, J. J., joined.
Shore participated in the discussions without believing that any new terms would be acceptable, and during the referendum he joined with other anti-EEC ' dissenting ministers ' in opposing membership.
Justice Antonin Scalia filed a dissenting opinion, in which Justice Clarence Thomas joined.
These dissenting " Anti-Missourian Brotherhood " congregations joined in 1890 with the Norwegian Augustana Synod and the Norwegian-Danish Conference to form the United Norwegian Lutheran Church of America ( Norwegian: Den Forenede Kirke ).
; Adams v. Williams ( 1972 ); ( dissenting opinion of Douglas, joined by Marshall ):
The dissenting opinion was written by William J. Brennan, who was joined by Byron White, Thurgood Marshall, and Lewis Franklin Powell.
The Court had voted 7 – 2 ( with Brandeis joined by Holmes dissenting ) against Ruthenberg.
0.476 seconds.