[permalink] [id link]
Lyell rejected Lamarck's idea of organic evolution, proposing instead " Centres of Creation " to explain diversity and territory of species.
from
Wikipedia
Some Related Sentences
Lyell and rejected
In the second volume of the first edition of Principles Lyell explicitly rejected the mechanism of Lamark on the transmutation of species, and was doubtful whether species were mutable.
Lyell and Lamarck's
Lyell first received a copy of one of Lamarck's books from Mantell in 1827, when he was on circuit.
Darwin's daughter Henrietta ( Etty ) wrote to her father: " Is it fair that Lyell always calls your theory a modification of Lamarck's?
Although the geologist Charles Lyell opposed scriptural geology he also believed in the immutability of species, and in his Principles of Geology ( 1830 – 1833 ), criticized and dismissed Lamarck's theories of development.
Lyell uncomfortably joked that from " Lamarck's view " this gave a long time " for their tails to wear off ", but Darwin was beginning to look at these " wonderful " fossils in an evolutionary light.
Charles Lyell had thoroughly criticized Lamarck's ideas in the second edition of his monumental work Principles of Geology.
Lyell and idea
The geologist Charles Lyell built upon Hutton's ideas during the first half of 19th century and amassed observations in support of the uniformitarian idea that the Earth's features had been shaped by same geological processes that could be observed in the present acting gradually over an immense period of time.
Even many of Darwin's original supporters ( such as Alfred Russel Wallace and Charles Lyell ) balked at the idea that human beings could have evolved their apparently boundless mental capacities and moral sensibilities through natural selection.
However, he spelt out the details of Natural Selection to Lyell, who found the idea hard to accept but urged Darwin to publish to establish priority.
Other Christians were opposed to the idea and even some of Darwin's close friends and supporters including Charles Lyell and Asa Gray initially expressed reservations about some of his ideas.
" Lyell was still struggling to come to terms with the idea of mankind, with immortal soul, originating from animals, but " Considering his age, his former views and position in society, I think his conduct has been heroic on the subject.
Lyell still, however, remained deeply critical of Darwin's idea of natural selection.
Lyell and evolution
Although Darwin discussed evolutionary ideas with him from 1842, Lyell continued to reject evolution in each of the first nine editions of the Principles.
He encouraged Darwin to publish, and following the 1859 publication of On the Origin of Species, Lyell finally offered a tepid endorsement of evolution in the tenth edition of Principles.
Lyell was also a friend of Darwin's closest colleagues, Hooker and Huxley, but unlike them he struggled to square his religious beliefs with evolution.
Although Lyell did not publicly accept evolution ( descent with modification ) at the time of writing the Principles, after the Darwin – Wallace papers and the Origin Lyell wrote in his notebook:
Restatements of his geological ideas ( though not his thoughts on evolution ) by John Playfair in 1802 and then Charles Lyell in the 1830s popularised the concept of an infinitely repeating cycle, though Lyell tended to dismiss Hutton's views as giving too much credence to catastrophic changes.
When presenting his ideas against the prevailing influences of catastrophism and progressive creationism, which envisaged species being supernaturally created at intervals, Darwin needed to forcefully stress the gradual nature of evolution in accordance with the gradualism promoted by his friend Charles Lyell.
Malthus on population, James Hutton and Lyell on geology, Darwin's Voyage of the Beagle, and above all, the anonymous Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation, which put evolution into everyday discussion amongst literate folk.
Charles Darwin was a follower of Lyell's theory of uniformitarianism and decided to expand upon Lyell ’ s theory with a quantitative estimate to determine if there was enough time in the history of the earth to uphold his principles of evolution.
James Hutton and Charles Lyell also contributed to early understanding of the Earth's history with their observations at Edinburgh in Scotland concerning angular unconformity in a rock face and it was in fact Lyell that influenced Charles Darwin greatly in his theory of evolution by speculating that the present is the key to the past.
Jean-Baptiste Lamarck-Lamarckism-landrace-Language-Last common ancestor-Last universal ancestor-Richard Lewontin-list of gene families-List of human evolution fossils-life-history theory-Wen-Hsiung Li-living fossils-Charles Lyell
This made guarded comments about evolution, and in the spring of 1856 it was noticed by Lyell who drew it to the attention of Darwin who was then working out a strategy for presenting his theory.
Opposition in the scientific community, led by influential scientists like the anatomists Georges Cuvier and Richard Owen and the geologist Charles Lyell, to these early theories of evolution was intense.
This started Lyell rethinking his opposition to evolution, and he tipped off Darwin who appears to have taken little notice of Wallace's guarded comments at this point.
Darwin made his views clearer to others, telling Lyell that if each step in evolution was providentially planned, the whole procedure would be a miracle and natural selection superfluous.
However, Lyell avoided a definitive statement on human evolution.
Lyell, now nearly blind and in deteriorating health, wrote to Darwin applauding the boost to " you and your theory of evolution " despite his qualms about the hereafter.
Mount Lyell is a mountain in the West Coast Range, Tasmania, named by Charles Gould in 1863 Charles Lyell was named during the nineteenth century controversy about the theory of evolution put forward by Charles Darwin, Lyell was a supporter of Darwin's.
: Note-the Mountains named after Charles Lyell were done so in the nineteenth century during the controversy about Charles Darwin's theory of evolution.
Lyell and proposing
He was a great and objective scientist and poked fun at some of the more outlandish theories of the time, such as that put forward by Charles Lyell, proposing that geological and biological history were cyclical and that ancient life forms would again walk the earth.
Lyell and instead
He was clearly dissociating himself from the new ideas of Charles Lyell which he had accepted during the voyage, and from Darwin's account which embraced these ideas, instead asserting a new commitment under the influence of his very religious wife to the doctrine of the established Church of England.
But instead of attacking Lyell directly, he did it by publicly ridiculing Maria Callcott ’ s observations.
Lyell and Creation
Books by the eminent geologist Charles Lyell had influenced the young Darwin during the Voyage of the Beagle and he then befriended Darwin who he saw as a supporter of his ideas of gradual geological processes with continuing divine Creation of species.
The eminent geologist Charles Lyell, whose books had influenced the young Darwin during the Voyage of the Beagle, befriended Darwin who he saw as a supporter of his ideas of gradual geological processes with continuing divine Creation of species.
For Lyell this was " a glorious addition to my society of geologists ", gentlemen ( and amateurs of independent means ) with duty only to scientific integrity, social stability and responsible religion, for Darwin it meant joining the respectable élite of eminent geologists developing a science dealing with the age of the earth and the Days of Creation.
Lyell and explain
One of the contributions that Lyell made in Principles was to explain the cause of earthquakes.
* Charles Lyell publishes the first volume of his Principles of Geology, being an attempt to explain the former changes of the Earth's surface, by reference to causes now in operation.
Lyell and territory
Lyell was convinced that animals were also driven to spread their territory by overpopulation, but Darwin went further in applying the Whig social thinking of struggle for survival with no handouts.
Lyell and species
By the early 19th century biogeography was ignited through efforts of Alexander von Humboldt, Lyell and Darwin ; their efforts, while important in relating species to their environments, were part of the naturalist tradition and fell short of conservation biology proper.
On 20 February 1836, Herschel had written to Lyell praising his Principles of Geology as opening a way for bold speculation on " that mystery of mysteries, the replacement of extinct species by others.
Early in 1842, Darwin wrote about his ideas to Lyell, who noted that his ally " denies seeing a beginning to each crop of species ".
His studies on the relations of the fossil to the recent species led him as early as 1829 to conclusions somewhat similar to those arrived at by Lyell, to whom Deshayes rendered much assistance in connection with the classification of the Tertiary system into Eocene, Miocene and Pliocene.
From 1830 to 1833, the geologist and clergyman Sir Charles Lyell released a three volume publication called Principles of Geology, which developed Hutton's ideas of uniformitarianism, and in the second volume set out a gradualist variation of creation beliefs in which each species had its " centre of creation " and was designed for the habitat, but would go extinct when the habitat changed.
John Herschel supported this gradualist view and wrote to Lyell urging a search for natural laws underlying the " mystery of mysteries " of how species formed.
Lyell, dismayed that his erstwhile ally had become a Transmutationist, noted that Darwin " denies seeing a beginning to each crop of species ".
Lyell seemed to be coming round to Darwin's ideas, but in private was agonising over the social implications if humans had animal ancestry, particularly now that race was becoming an issue, with Robert Knox describing races as different species and warning of racial wars.
Lyell saw a " law of succession " with mammals being replaced by their own kind on each continent, and on 17 February used his presidential address at the Geographical Society to present Owen's findings to date on Darwin's fossils, pointing out this inference that extinct species were related to current species in the same locality.
In a letter to Lyell, Herschel had written of “ that mystery of mysteries, the replacement of extinct species by others ”.
" He needed an ally, and hinted to Lyell that his work was " bearing on the question of species ", amassing " facts, which begin to group themselves clearly under sub-laws.
He told Lyell that the range of brain sizes between people was greater than the difference between small-brained people and gorillas, and " Under these circumstances it would certainly be well to let go the head ( as a way of distinguishing species ) though I am afraid it does not mend matters much to lay hold of the foot.
To Darwin's disappointment Lyell had still not brought himself to clearly endorse Darwin's theory on species or on man, though he had " spoken out ... even beyond my state of feeling as to man's unbroken descent from the brutes ".
By June Lyell was struggling to revise his Principles of Geology, though Darwin still hoped that he would at last " speak out plainly about species ".
In October 1845 he wrote to his friend Charles Lyell that Segwick's review was a " grand piece of argument against mutability of species " which he had read with " fear & trembling ," but had been " well pleased to find " that he had anticipated Sedgwick's objections and " had not overlooked any of the arguments ".
The species name comes from Dawson's teacher, the geologist Sir Charles Lyell.
0.511 seconds.