Page "Achai Gaon" Paragraph 10

( 1 ) The first edition of the " Sheiltot " appeared in Venice, 1546, and was succeeded by the following: ( 2 ) An edition with a short commentary by Isaiah Berlin ( Dyhernfurth, 1786 ); ( 3 ) another under the title תועפות ראם, with the commentary of Isaac Pardo, Salonica, 1800 – 01 ; ( 4 ) with an extended commentary by Naphtali Ẓebi Judah Berlin ( Wilna, 1861, 1864, 1867 ), which latter edition contains the commentary of Isaiah Berlin, as well as a number of variant readings taken from a manuscript of the year 1460, and a short commentary by Saul ben Joseph, who probably lived in the first half of the 14th century.

Manuscripts of the Sheiltot, but with essential divergences from the printed text, are to be found among the Hebrew manuscripts in the Bibliothèque Nationale, Paris, Nos.

308, 309, and in the Bodleian Library, Oxford, Nos.

539, 540, 1317.

In the latter library may be found also the hitherto unprinted commentaries by Solomon ben Shabbethai ( 541 ), and Johanan ben Reuben ( 542 ).