[permalink] [id link]
Factortame sought, first, a preliminary injunction declaring that the offending part of the 1988 Act could not be applied to them on the grounds that such application would be contrary to directly effective rights under EU law, specifically the right not to be discriminated against on the grounds of nationality ( article 7 of the Treaty of Rome ), the right of individuals and companies to establish themselves in business anywhere in the EU ( articles 43 – 48 ), and the right to participate in the capital of companies situated in another Member State ( article 294 ).
from
Wikipedia
Some Related Sentences
Factortame and sought
Firstly, the relief sought required the court to order positive action in the shape of the disapplication of the 1988 Act and the application of the 1894 Act ; were Factortame not to succeed before the ECJ, the House of Lords would have " conferred upon them rights directly contrary to Parliament's sovereign will ".
He first noted that the injunction sought by Factortame would in fact be available in all Member States except the UK and Denmark.
Factortame and first
Secondly, the prospects of Factortame succeeding in a full trial of the case once the ECJ had given its ruling on the compatibility of the 1988 Act ; in this regard, the House of Lords took into account indications from the ECJ's first ruling that Factortame's arguments had ' considerable force '.
Factortame and injunction
The questions posed essentially asked whether, in the circumstances of the case, Community law overrode English law and either empowered or obliged UK courts to grant the injunction claimed by Factortame.
On 11 October 1990 the House of Lords gave its judgment in the light of the ECJ's ruling and granted an injunction in favour of Factortame.
Factortame and offending
The matter came back to the Divisional Court ( Hobhouse LJ, Collins J and Moses LJ ) which ruled on 31 July 1997 that the UK had committed a sufficiently serious breach of Community law in passing the offending provisions of the Merchant Shipping Act 1988, and that that breach gave rise to damage for which Factortame should be compensated.
Factortame and part
* R v Secretary of State, ex parte Factortame Ltd ( No 1 ) ( 22 March 1989 ) part of the Factortame saga establishing the principle of EU law supremacy where the UK has delegated sovereignty under the treaties
The Judge therefore rejected claims by Factortame in respect of other fishing vessels which had been refused registration under the 1988 Act, but which had not formed part of the original claim lodged in 1988, nor had been claimed before July 1996.
Factortame and 1988
This meant that other claims against the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 would only be admissible if they had been lodged by 10 July 1996 ( i. e. six years from the House of Lords ' decision of 9 July 1990 granting Factortame interim relief ), if not such claims were statute-barred.
Factortame and Act
Amongst the early beneficiaries of the 1894 Act was Factortame Limited, a company whose directors were Joseph J L Couceiro, John A Couceiro and Ken L Couceiro, all Spanish nationals resident and domiciled in Spain.
Factortame had argued that claims for discrimination under European law were broadly comparable to claims for discrimination to individuals under the Race Relations Act 1976.
Factortame and could
The apparent exceptions to this rule are situations in which Parliament has chosen to limit itself as with the case of implemention of European Union law in which Parliament has given the European Court of Justice authority to strike down UK legislation that it deems to be contrary to EU law ( see Factortame case ), but could withdraw such authority.
Such a result could not occur under parliamentary sovereignty ( or at least not before Factortame ) as a statute was law and its validity could not be questioned in any court.
Factortame and be
However, in 1972 the UK signed up to be a member of the European Union, and with this accepted European law to be supreme in certain areas ( see the ex parte Factortame case ).
Firstly, the likelihood that Factortame would suffer hardship and loss, were relief not to be allowed.
In the case where a State had exercised broad discretion in passing legislation which breached Community law ( as was the case in Factortame ), for the breach to be " sufficiently serious " it must be " manifest " and " grave ".
The Factortame case has produced large amounts of academic debate as to whether it can be reconciled with the idea of legislative supremacy as stated by Dicey.
Factortame and on
The Factortame case provided the court for an opportunity to elaborate on the principles underlying the liability of Member States.
The House of Lords unanimously ruled in favour of Factortame on 28 October 1999.
Factortame and would
This principle would itself come into question as a consequence of EEC membership in the Factortame litigation.
Factortame and EU
In the famous Factortame case, the House of Lords ( Lord Bridge ) has interpreted this provision as inserting an implied clause into all UK statutes that they shall not apply where they conflict with European law, in what was seen as a major departure from the English constitutional doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty ( see Factortame: Sovereignty and the EU ).
The Factortame litigation led to a series of landmark decisions in United Kingdom ( UK ) and European Union ( EU ) law.
" In the same way that Parliament had introduced legislation to remedy areas of UK law which did not meet the standards set by EU directives, the House of Lords was now accomplishing the same task in giving judgment for Factortame.
Factortame and law
The Judge also rejected an attempt by Factortame to obtain damages for injury to feelings and aggravated damages caused by the government's breach of Community law.
Factortame and ),
* Michael Mann ( judge ) ( 1930 – 1998 ), Lord Justice of Appeal of the Court of Appeal of England and Wales, see Factortame litigation
Factortame and companies
In March 2000, Factortame and the other claimants ( approximately 90 Anglo-Spanish fishing companies ) accepted an offer of settlement from the Secretary of State.
Factortame and ).
Laws made by the Union supersede those made by national governments ( See: Factortame case ).
sought and first
On the positivist theory, everything I sought to express by calling it evil in the first case is still present in the second.
But everyone I met had sought cover first and asked questions later.
Pelham said Sunday night there was research being done on whether the `` quickie '' vote on the increase can be repealed outright or whether notice would have to first be given that reconsideration of the action would be sought.
While Renaissance artists sought nature to find their style, the Mannerists looked first for a style and found a manner. In Mannerist paintings, compositions can have no focal point, space can be ambiguous, figures can be characterized by an athletic bending and twisting with distortions, exaggerations, an elastic elongation of the limbs, bizarre posturing on one hand, graceful posturing on the other hand, and a rendering of the heads as uniformly small and oval.
The Radicals in the House of Representatives impeached him in 1868 ( a first for a U. S. president ), charging him with violating the Tenure of Office Act, when he sought to remove his Secretary of War without Senate approval ; his trial in the Senate ended in an acquittal by a single vote.
In this term, he introduced for the first time his Homestead Bill, which sought to provide 160 acres for every poor family head " without money and without price "; Johnson did not rest until passage some years later.
In a second effort at compromise, Trumbull presented for Johnson's signature the first Civil Rights Bill, which sought to grant citizenship to the freedmen.
The Radicals in the House of Representatives impeached him in 1868 ( a first for a U. S. president ), charging him with violating the Tenure of Office Act, when he sought to remove his Secretary of War without Senate approval ; nevertheless, his trial in the Senate ended in an acquittal by a single vote.
From the unexpected realism of his first major figure — inspired by his 1875 trip to Italy — to the unconventional memorials whose commissions he later sought, Rodin's reputation grew, such that he became the preeminent French sculptor of his time.
Also, the court pointed out that, while Canada has the power to amend the line of succession to the Canadian throne, the Statute of Westminster stipulates that the agreement of the governments of the fifteen other Commonwealth realms that share the Crown would first have to be sought if Canada wished to continue its relationship with these countries.
At first, he sought an understanding with the Abbasids, but when they refused his terms and demanded his submission, Ibn Habib broke openly with the Abbasids and invited the remnants of the Umayyad dynasty to take refuge in his dominions.
Bonaparte had sought to invade Egypt, as the first step in a campaign against British India whose ultimate aim was to drive Britain out of the French Revolutionary Wars.
The Survey sent him to Europe five times, first in 1871 as part of a group sent to observe a solar eclipse ; there, he sought out Augustus De Morgan, William Stanley Jevons, and William Kingdon Clifford, British mathematicians and logicians whose turn of mind resembled his own.
Most football clubs were founded first, and then sought grounds in which to play, but Chelsea were founded for Stamford Bridge.
Other advantages are that one can easily find the first or last elements on the list ( most likely to be useful in the case of numerically sorted data ), or elements in a given range ( useful again in the case of numerical data, and also with alphabetically ordered data when one may be sure of only the first few letters of the sought item or items ).
Rather he believed he had rediscovered first century beliefs from the Bible alone, and sought to prove that through a process of challenge and debate and writing journals.
In World War II rivals who had combat service in the first great war ( led by Gen. Bernard Montgomery ) sought to denigrate Eisenhower for his previous lack of combat duty, despite his stateside experience establishing a camp, completely equipped, for thousands of troops, and developing a full combat training schedule.
It was during her performances in the carnival that Day first caught the attention of Barney Rapp, who sought a girl vocalist and asked if Day would like to audition for the job.
Hopkinson claimed to have designed the official " first flag " of the United States and sought compensation from Congress.
This issue came to the fore in the first part of the eleventh century when Rome and the pope sought autonomy from the Holy Roman Emperor.
In the book The Wild Frontier: Atrocities during the American-Indian War from Jamestown Colony to Wounded Knee, amateur historian William M. Osborn sought to tally every recorded atrocity in the area that would eventually become the continental United States, from first contact ( 1511 ) to the closing of the frontier ( 1890 ), and determined that 7, 193 people died from atrocities perpetrated by whites, and 9, 156 people died from atrocities perpetrated by Native Americans.
From the time Lucrezia had first arrived in Ferrara as Alfonso's intended bride, Isabella, despite having acted as hostess during the wedding festivities, had regarded Lucrezia as a rival, whom she sought to outdo at every opportunity.
The Treaty of Amity, Commerce, and Navigation concluded in 1888 between Japan and Mexico was the nation's first " equal " treaty with any country ; which overshadows Tokugawa Ieyasu's pre-Edo period initiatives which sought to establish official relations with the New Spain in Mexico.
In interior policy, Haidallah sought to improve relations between White Moors and Black Moors, among other things officially decreeing the ban of slavery for the first time in the country's history, but he neither tried nor achieved a radical break with the sectarian and discriminating policies of previous regimes.
0.467 seconds.